← All lanesMeasured October 19, 2026
Chicago, IL to New York, NY: tolls, diesel and what it nets
Representative load: 42,000 lbs, 5 axles, 6.5 mpg, paying $2,050.00 ($2.60 a mile). No driver wage line.
The verdict
$318.08 more in your pocket, for 1h 17m extra on the road.
That works out to $247.16 for each extra hour on the trip. Whether that is worth it is your call — the figures for both are below.
Fastest vs most profitable
Door to door
23h 52m
1d 1h 9m
Diesel
$804.58 · 121.2 gal
$802.72 · 124.2 gal
$318.08 more in your pocket, for 1h 17m extra on the road.
Green: the most profitable road. Grey: the fastest.
States crossed
IL → IN → OH → PA → NJ → NY
Mandated stops
Placed by the hours-of-service rules, with the diesel the plan buys at each.
Most profitable plan
1. 30-minute break · OH · mile 281 · fill 82 gallons at ~$6.37
2. 10-hour rest · PA · mile 662
Fastest plan
1. 30-minute break · PA · mile 506
2. 10-hour rest · PA · mile 692
Nearby lanes
Every lane we measuredMeasured on October 19, 2026 on that day's state diesel prices, with tolls priced for 5 axles. Your load, your truck and the pump will differ.
Questions drivers ask
How much are tolls from Chicago, IL to New York, NY for a 5-axle truck?
We measured $451.66 on the fastest road and $128.25 on the most profitable one, priced for 5 axles on October 19, 2026.
How much diesel does a truck burn from Chicago, IL to New York, NY?
About 121.2 gallons on the fastest road (812 miles at 6.7 mpg loaded), costing $804.58 at the state diesel prices of October 19, 2026.
How long does it take to drive a truck from Chicago, IL to New York, NY?
On the fastest road, 13h 22m of driving and 23h 52m door to door once the mandated breaks and rest are in. The most profitable plan takes 1d 1h 9m door to door and nets $318.08 more.
Your rate, your truck, your lane.
These figures are for one representative load. Run your own with your rate, axle count and fuel economy and see both roads priced the same way.
Run your lane with your rate — 3 free